Decision A-0704.95

Case Number Claimant Judge Language Decision date
Decision A-0704.95 Savarie Micheline  Federal  French 1996-09-27
Decision Appealed Appellant Corresponding Case
Allowed Unanimous  No Commission  29246 


Issue: Sub-Issue 1: Sub-Issue 2: Sub-Issue 3:
earnings  allocation  by reason of separation 

Summary:

Teacher who received $545 as accumulated sick leave when her employment contract expired. Umpire found that Kinkead (A-217-93) applied, that the compensation was a direct result of the work contract and that the separation merely provided the opportunity. Judgment overturned by the FCA. The FCA reiterated its position taken in Kinkead, explaining that the Umpire had shifted the focus. Payment was made "as a result of" the separation, within the meaning of the text, when it became due and payable upon actual termination of the employment. The obligation it was intended to fulfil was only potential as long as the job continued and would only materialize, becoming liquid and payable, when the employment actually came to an end.


Issue: Sub-Issue 1: Sub-Issue 2: Sub-Issue 3:
earnings  income  paid or payable 

Summary:

Teacher who received $545 as accumulated sick leave when her employment contract expired. Umpire found that Kinkead (A-217-93) applied, that the compensation was a direct result of the work contract and that the separation merely provided the opportunity. Judgment overturned by the FCA. The FCA reiterated its position taken in Kinkead, explaining that the Umpire had shifted the focus. Payment was made "as a result of" the separation, within the meaning of the text, when it became due and payable upon actual termination of the employment. The obligation it was intended to fulfil was only potential as long as the job continued and would only materialize, becoming liquid and payable, when the employment actually came to an end.


Date modified: