Decision A-0520.01

Case Number Claimant Judge Language Decision date
Decision A-0520.01 Tousignant Suzanne  Federal  English 2002-06-11
Decision Appealed Appellant Corresponding Case
Judicial Review Dismissed  No Commission  51759 


Issue: Sub-Issue 1: Sub-Issue 2: Sub-Issue 3:
earnings  awards  nature of monies 

Summary:

After 18 years, claimant left her employment because of health problems. She was awarded a settlement equivalent to 24 months for wrongful dismissal. An appropriate rule of thumb to fix a period of damages for wrongful dismissal was to award one month for each year of service. Claimant claimed that the additional 6 months was for the mental duress she had been subjected. Based on these facts, the Umpire ruled that the extra 6 months should not be considered as earnings and not be allocated. The Court found that it was open for the Umpire to make that decision and summarily dismissed the Commission's request for judicial review.


Issue: Sub-Issue 1: Sub-Issue 2: Sub-Issue 3:
earnings  awards  rationale 

Summary:

After 18 years, claimant left her employment because of health problems. She was awarded a settlement equivalent to 24 months for wrongful dismissal. An appropriate rule of thumb to fix a period of damages for wrongful dismissal was to award one month for each year of service. Claimant claimed that the additional 6 months was for the mental duress she had been subjected. Based on these facts, the Umpire ruled that the extra 6 months should not be considered as earnings and not be allocated. The Court found that it was open for the Umpire to make that decision and summarily dismissed the Commission's request for judicial review.


Date modified: